March 3, 2010 at 7:11 pm (Juvanalia, Literature, Romance, Young adult) (, , )

Greensleeves by Eliose Jarvis McGraw

Greensleeves by Eloise Jarvis McGraw
Harcourt Brace & World, 1st edition, 1968
311 pages
Genre: Young adult, literature, Bildungsroman

Synopsis & Review: Shannon Lightley was in despair. Tired of being dragged about Europe from school to school in the wake of her divorced parents—her mother a famous English actress, her father a prominent television news commentator—she had taken her last year of high school in a small Oregon town, only to find that she didn’t “belong” in her native America either.

Reached by an old friend of her father’s—a lawyer in Portland—just as she was on the verge of leaving for Europe again, Shannon undertook the assignment he offered her, to track down some odd strangers, living near the local university, who were involved in an unusual will that was being contested. Using an assumed name and working as a waitress in a campus diner, Shannon was entirely on her own for the first time in her life, and as the summer went by, she tried t sort out who she really was and where her future lay. (jacket copy)

At Jenny’s behest (and because I do love Eloise Jarvis McGraw’s Moccasin Trail), I checked Greensleeves out from the MCL, and OH MY GOD, I LOVED IT. Greensleeves has a lot to offer: alienation, a world-weary girl expat on the verge of womanhood, investigating a mystery while disguised as her polar opposite, two men who both see through her disguise to the worth beneath, someone finding themselves after high school, and blue eyeshadow. (I love blue eyeshadow. I have LOTS of it)

Shannon is a fish out of water in Oregon; everything about her, from her accent and clothes, to her education and her very hair, sets her apart from the very ordinary college students surrounding her at the Rainbow Café. But despite these ultimately superficial differences—which she hides by assuming an identity as one Georgetta Einszweiler Smith of Morton Center, Idaho—how different is Shannon really? She’s afraid of the person she was or thinks she is, she’s afraid to be herself, and unsure what “being herself” really means? By hiding Shannon beneath Georgetta, and then beneath Greensleeves, Shannon can avoid having to answer those questions. It sometimes seems as though she might try to avoid all of life just by hanging on to her new persona instead of making choices about where her life will go.

But she doesn’t. Coaxed out of hiding by Sherry, one of those young men who sees though the Georgetta disguise to–well, he isn’t sure what’s beneath it, but he knows that there’s something there, Shannon finds that she can talk to people, that people will not only accept her, but like her. She figures out that maybe college isn’t like high school, and that it may open opportunities for her rather than slamming doors closed in her face. Much of Shannon’s self-discovery is also entwined with the mystery she’s been set to solve, investigating the various beneficiaries to a will. Each of those beneficiaries is a fully-realized character, with strengths and weaknesses Shannon can learn from, until she learns the lesson that Mrs Elizabeth Dunningham couldn’t.

Greensleeves is beautifully written, and why it’s no longer in print is a mystery to me. A walking bundle of adolescent anxieties and insecurities, Shannon vacillates wildly from mature to immature, sometimes in one breath, but the self-possession she gains over the course of the story charms. Greensleeves has a certain pathos that evokes other Bildungsroman like I Capture the Castle—particularly the ending, which is very indefinite, but all the more realistic because of it. And did I mention how much I love the ending, and how beautiful it is? Shoots, I would call Greensleeves the American I Capture the Castle in its moving portrayal of a young woman becoming aware of her sense of self and her capacity for love—and on what terms she is willing to take love offered. The next time I have fifty bucks to drop on a book, it’ll be on Greensleeves fo sho.

Read also: I Capture the Castle by Dodie Smith, Moccasin Trail by Eloise Jarvis McGraw

Cover: My library copy was permabound long ago, but the cover I see online is no great loss. It’s very Sixties in it’s orange and yellowness, and looks really busy, but appears to be Shannon crying? Hmm.

“Oh, you don’t need French to go to France, dear,” Helen told me with a kindly smile. “Everybody in Europe speaks English now. They’re glad to.”
Oh, are they really, I thought. Funnily enough, I can’t recall one single
enfant de la patrie who’ll speak anything but French unless he has to. I seem to remember that Austrians prefer German, too, and Italians Italian, etc., etc. However, I feel certain that even if Helen went to Outer Mongolia, she’d hunt up the Hilton–I assume there’s an Outer Mongolian Hilton–where she’d be sure of air conditioning and Cokes, and everybody at a Hilton would speak English, so the whole thing would be as easy as taking a nap. Helen’s always going to find the easy way–I feel one can rely on that absolutely. Well, it’s her nap. Presumably, she doesn’t even want to wake up.

2 February – 3 February



  1. Jenny said,

    Literally shrieked out loud when I saw in Google Reader the title of this post, and then I was all heart-in-throaty waiting for the page to load and then did some more shrieking when I saw you loved it. Yay! I’m so happy! Isn’t it great? I completely agree with you about its being like I Capture the Castle, btw; in fact I think I said that to someone the other day.

    Helen, by the way, cracks me up every time I read this book.

    • Schatzi said,

      I knew you would be excited!

      I am really, really, really glad that you mentioned it, because otherwise, I doubt I would have ever come across it. Someone needs to get the word out!

      • Jenny said,

        I know! I wish I could tell everyone all the time about this book! But I am doing a guest post about it later on this month at Aarti’s blog, Book Lust, and I think she has a pretty wide readership. *crosses fingers*

      • Schatzi said,

        Oh, how excellent!

        And re: Helen, I have to say, I was really hoping Shannon would bust out some marvelous French on her one day.

  2. 2010 To Be Read Challenge (5/12) « the stacks my destination said,

    […] Racquin by Emile Zola A Tangled Web by L.M. Montgomery Can You Forgive Her? by Anthony Trollope Greensleeves by Eloise Jarvis McGraw The Game of Kings by Dorothy Dunnett Dear Enemy by Jean […]

  3. A Ring of Endless Light « the stacks my destination said,

    […] also: A Wrinkle in Time, Meet the Austins, The Moon by Night by Madeline L’Engle, Greensleeves by Eloise Jarvis McGraw, I Capture the Castle by Dodie […]

  4. The Egypt Game « the stacks my destination said,

    […] this one and Eyes in the Fishbowl put me in mind of Greensleeves; I think it’s that crazy Sixties vibe. The illustrations alone are amazing, and perfect for […]

  5. Tina said,

    I adore this book as well!! I haven’t read I Capture the Castle, but if it’s anything like Greensleeves, I’m off to find it asap! Thanks for the recommendation! I’d love to invite you to join Booknificent Thursdays on my blog,, every Thursday! If you love Greensleeves, you’re a friend for life in my book! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: